8 Next-Level Grilled Cheese Spots in Chicagoland

Here are some of our favorite spots to get your grilled cheese fix.

As parents, when we see grilled cheese on the kid’s menu at restaurants, we often let out a huge sigh of relief knowing that the establishment wins the child picky eater seal of approval, making it acceptable for our family to dine. 

While this simple staple is often associated with kids, many Chicagoland restaurants are catering to adults by taking the concept of grilled cheese sandwiches and elevating them to the next level.

From Texas toast bread to tomato soup dipping sauces, here are some of our favorite spots to get your grilled cheese fix in.  

Note: We’re updating our website as quickly as we can, but changes may occur due to COVID-19. Please double check before heading out for the most updated information on safety precautions and any last-minute cancellations. Stay safe!

Cheesies Pub & Grub

Chicago’s first grilled cheese restaurant takes grilled cheese very seriously. They offer simple sandwiches made on Texas toast and souped-up versions with options like fried chicken tenders, coleslaw and pulled pork. We love their homemade dipping sauces most, which are tomato soup, pesto mayo and ranch

Everdine’s Grilled Cheese Company

As if it weren’t enough to put every mouth-watering grilled cheese sandwich on buttery, crispy Texas toast, Everdine’s also tops their more than 15 sandwiches off with mac and cheese, buffalo chicken and tuna salad. Can’t find the perfect combo? Make your own.

Gayle V’s Best Ever Grilled Cheese 

If you’ve ever been to a farmers market around town, chances are you’ve sampled Gayle V’s grilled cheese. Now with a storefront in Block 37, guests can enjoy a selection of farm fresh cheeses (Butterkäse, Swiss, white cheddar) on delicious bread from local bakeries. 

Grilled Cheese Society

  • Available on: Door Dash, Grubhub and Postmates

This cloud kitchen service concept came from Texas and draws inspiration from its roots, featuring more than a dozen sammys, including its Signature, which is loaded with pepper Jack cheese, chorizo, queso fresco, roasted jalapenos and red peppers. 

Jefferson Tap

Simplicity shines at this West Loop eatery, which has made a name for itself with its reminiscent-of-childhood grilled cheese sandwich — sourdough bread topped with two different kinds of cheese, tomato and avocado. We’re also big fans of their tots. 

Jerry’s Sandwiches

If you haven’t tried the Munchy M grilled cheese sandwich, your palette is in for a treat. This simple grilled American and cheddar sandwich gets a flavor boost from its added layers- avocado, chips, pickled jalapeno, cilantro and southwest mayo. 

The Fat Shallot

This grilled cheese sandwich is the perfect bite. Enjoy sourdough bread complete with ooey, gooey Munster cheese, sauteed spinach, and caramelized onions. In addition to the Lincoln Park space, there’s a second location at Revival Food Hall. Fans can also catch a third fix with The Fat Shallot Food Truck roaming around Chicago. 

Toasty Cheese Mobile Eatery

From Schaumburg to Wheeling, The Toasty Cheese Mobile Eatery delights hungry customers with their small but tasty menu serving classics like Cheddar and American on white bread to artisan creations with duck bacon, provolone, spinach, and Sicilian cherry tomatoes. 

Follow Chicago Parent on Instagram.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -


Having a Baby After 35: My ‘Over the Hill’ Pregnancy

One mom shares on how she really feels about her so-called 'geriatric pregnancy.'

Family Neighborhood Guide: Pullman

Get to know Chicago's Pullman Historic District with these places to eat, play, explore and shop.

Lunar New Year 2022 Guide for Chicago Families

The holiday falls on Feb. 1.

Lunar New Year Books to Read with Kids

Celebrate Lunar New Year with these books!

- Advertisement -