Frankenstein Monster Toe Cookies

Allergy-friendly! These make a great addition to any Halloween celebration. The original recipe calls for dyed almonds as the toenails, but because of my daughters’ nut allergy, I substituted colorful jelly beans and most kids seem to prefer my version, allergies or not.


  • 1 pouch (1 lb. 1.5 oz.) Betty Crocker sugar cookie mix. (Or use your favorite from-scratch sugar cookie recipe and add the neon green food coloring to finished dough. Eliminate the added flour, butter, egg and vanilla.)
  • 1/4 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1/3 cup melted butter or margarine
  • 1 large egg
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract (I use McCormick)
  • 7 drops NEON green food color (McCormick makes this–check the supermarket baking aisle)
  • 36 Mike and Ike or other “safe” jelly beans such as Surf Sweets or Vermont Nut-Free


  1. In large bowl stir cookie mix, flour, melted butter, egg, vanilla and green food color until soft dough forms. Cover and refrigerate for one hour.
  2. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. For each cookie, roll heaping teaspoons of dough into 2-1/2 inch finger shapes. Be careful not to make the shapes too big or too flat–the dough spreads a lot during baking!
  3. About 1 inch from the end of each “toe” squeeze dough slightly.With knife, gently make lines in the dough to look like”knuckles”
  4. Bake 6-8 minutes until set. The edges of the cookies should not be at all brown. While still on cookie sheet and working quickly before cookies cool, gently but firmly press a jelly bean into the edge of each “toe” for the fingernail. Cool cookies one minute; remove to cooling racks. Let cool completely, about 15 minutes.

Makes 36 cookies.

Jenny Kales is the mother of two girls, one with severe nut allergies. She writes about her experiences atThe Nut-Free Mom blog, where you can find more allergy-friendly recipes. Contact Jenny at

- Advertisement -

Latest Stories

5 Sweet Maple Syrup Events in Chicagoland

Maple syrup season begins in late February.

8 Anti-Racism Videos to Watch with Your Kids

Add these YouTube videos to your playlist.

Summer Is the Best Time to Learn Spanish

Brought to you by Instituto Cervantes.

- Advertisement -