If you're craving that old-fashioned pie baked from scratch, Hoosier Mama Pie Shop will feel just like your own mama made it. There are the classics like apple, pumpkin and banana cream all rolled, peeled and made by hand. Each day there are more than 10 options of sweet pies, quiches and savory pies available. And for a real treat that was even featured on The Food Network, try the "Fat Elvis" pie made with chocolate, peanut butter and bananas in a graham cracker-peanut-pretzel crust. It's likely even better than your own mama could have made it.