Powered by

Is there 'something wrong' with kids with special needs?

 Email Print   
Friday, March 05, 2010

 

Recent posts

I.R.S. weighs in on breastfeeding - kind of - 2/11/2011

Baby Name of the Year ... The Situation? - 12/16/2010

Hanukkah's PR problem - 12/1/2010


RSSSubscribe to this blog

Enter your e-mail address to receive updates:

 
 
 

Yes, this is my second post in two days on NBC's new family drama, "Parenthood." But while Tuesday's post offered a general review of the show (good, not great), I wanted to take a few minutes to talk about something that happened in the final seconds of the premiere but that has had me thinking for three days.

Talking to his father, Adam Braverman (played by Peter Krause) says tearfully, "There's something wrong with my son." The son in question, Max, we find out, has Asperger's syndrome, a mild form of autism.

In the moment, I was hugely disappointed in NBC. While certainly autism is not the norm, many people with the disease, especially those with an Asperger's diagnosis, view it as a gift and see their abilities -- which often include an excellent memory, strong three-dimensional thinking, and musical or artistic ability -- as gifts.

Moreover, to label any child with a disability as "wrong" is hurtful, plain and simple. Some parents expressed those views on Access Hollywood last week, where they found an ally in host Billy Bush.

But something happened yesterday that made me rethink the situation. We got a comment on a story we ran in the most recent edition of Special Parent. The story was a profile of Kathy Lavin, a Chicago-area mom of three children, the oldest of whom has Down syndrome. At one point, Lavin is talking about the birth of her second child, Michael, and says: "...having Michael was a healing moment for me. It proved to me I could believe in myself to create something perfect."

One reader left the following comment:

So let me get this straight. Are you saying that people living with dissabilities [sic] aren't perfect? Are you saying that you are? Or are you telling your son that He alone is perfect?

The reader makes a fair, though perhaps a little harshly worded, point. And in light of that message, I rethought the "Parenthood" moment.

Of course, we shouldn't be reinforcing the idea that a child with special needs is fundamentally flawed or that, like all children, they're not a source of joy and inspiration for their parents. They are.

But in a sort of squeamish, uncomfortable way, I think we can all understand what parents of children with special needs like Adam or Kathy must feel, at least in the immediate aftermath. A sense of failure, perhaps? Of loss? Of disappointment? Of guilt?

Let's not judge Adam Braverman or Kathy Lavin or any of the millions of parents of children with special needs out there. As much as their children need to know that they are valued and loved, parents need to be reassured, comforted, validated, and, yes, maybe even allowed to indulge in a moment of politically incorrect guilt.

Being a parent is hard. Being a parent of child with special needs is unbelievably hard. They don't need your judgment on top of that.

Error parsing XSLT file: \xslt\article-detail.xslt

Our picks

 

Stay in touch

Be the first to know!

Events, coupons and contests by email

 
 
There is nothing wrong!

By Brooke Ashlee on Tuesday, November 13, 2012

I did not see the show either. Honestly I was just on google researching " is something wrong with autistic children". I am 17 years old and a senior in high school, most of you will probably stop reading there. But today I asked a ESE teacher that I have known for a long time, "Is there something wrong with your students, or do they just not learn as fast?" And he replied to me, "What do you mean something wrong?" To everyone reading this, whether you have a child with a disability, special needs or just have a handful there is nothing "wrong" with your child. God does not make mistakes. Those children and families that with special needs do not need your judgment or negative attention. They have enough to attend to. Before you tell me I do not know what I am talking about I also volunteer three days a week in an autistic classroom, at a local elementary school. BA

Mom of a boy with and SI disorder

By Heather F on Tuesday, November 13, 2012

First off I didn't see the show, we do not own a DVR or other said device and that new show aired opposite my favorite show-The Good Wife. I agree with you Liz-as parents of children with a disability, we need that moment to "grieve our perfect child". I love my son to bits!!! I wouldn't change him in the least, and I know that I am learning as much through him, as he is about the world. But I grieve his struggles, I grieve the hardships, I grieve that his disorder wasn't apparent until he was 4, and that we relied on the school system and they have failed us (Thanks be to God for the insurance covering some of his O.T.). It doesn't make me love him less, or my typically developing son more, it makes me human.

Directories

Entertainers/Party Supplies
Nannies
Home-based business
Resale