If he or she can't do the ONE job they are required to do, then they don't get the benefits that come along with the job. No TV, no outings, no fun, no extracurriculars. You have a time limit, otherwise a privilege is lost the next day. If it's a pattern, you lose privileges by week. If there's a bad grade, you lose privileges by month.
What do you want the panelists to weigh in on? Email your ideas to editor Tamara O'Shaughnessy at firstname.lastname@example.org.